Please call our customer service for cancellation.
Five Upselling Tactics That Increase Online Order Value Without Annoying Customers
Prasad Vemulapalli | November 04, 2026

 

Online ordering has made it easier for customers to browse menus, customize meals, and place orders in minutes. But for restaurants, getting more orders is only part of the opportunity. Increasing the value of each order can also improve revenue without requiring additional customers.

That's where smart upselling comes in.

Effective upselling isn't about pushing customers to spend more. It's about offering relevant choices that make their meals better, more convenient, or more complete.

When done correctly, upselling feels like helpful service rather than a sales pitch.

Here are five practical upselling tactics restaurants can use to increase average order value while keeping the online ordering experience simple and enjoyable.

1. Suggest Relevant Add-Ons at the Right Moment

Customers are more likely to consider an additional item when it naturally complements what they're already ordering.

Someone ordering a burger might appreciate the option to add fries, a drink, or an extra topping. A customer choosing pizza might be interested in garlic bread, dipping sauce, or a dessert.

The key is relevance.

Instead of displaying random menu items, restaurants should recommend products that make sense alongside the customer's selections.

How to make it work:

  • Recommend sides that complement the main dish.
  • Offer appropriate toppings and customizations.
  • Keep suggestions limited to a few relevant choices.
  • Display add-ons before the customer reaches the final checkout stage.

For example, a customer ordering a sandwich could see a simple suggestion:

"Make it a meal - add chips and a drink."

This approach works because the recommendation fits naturally into the ordering process.

Customers retain control, and the restaurant creates an opportunity to increase the order value without making the experience complicated.

2. Create Bundles That Offer Clear Value

Bundles are one of the simplest ways to encourage customers to purchase multiple items together.

Rather than asking customers to select every product separately, restaurants can group complementary items into convenient meal combinations.

A lunch bundle might include a sandwich, side, and drink. A family dinner bundle could combine multiple entrees with sides.

Bundles make ordering easier while giving customers a clear reason to consider spending more.

The most effective bundles have three characteristics:

  • The included items naturally belong together.
  • The combined price offers understandable value.
  • Customers can easily see what they receive.

For example, a restaurant might offer a burger for $11 or a burger meal with fries and a drink for $15.

The customer receives a more complete meal, while the restaurant increases the transaction value by $4.

A bundle doesn't always need a large discount. Convenience and simplicity can also make it attractive.

Avoid creating too many combinations. A few well-designed bundles are often easier to understand than a menu filled with overlapping offers.

3. Use Gentle Upgrades Instead of Aggressive Pop-Ups

Customers generally don't enjoy being interrupted repeatedly while placing an order.

Too many pop-ups, upsell messages, or checkout distractions can turn a convenient ordering experience into a frustrating one.

A better approach is to offer upgrades directly within the menu.

For example, restaurants can allow customers to select:

  • Regular or large portions.
  • Standard or premium ingredients.
  • Additional protein or toppings.
  • Upgraded sides or beverages.

These choices should appear naturally when customers customize their items.

Consider a customer ordering a salad. Offering grilled chicken for an additional $3 is more useful than displaying unrelated promotions.

The customer can quickly decide whether the upgrade fits their needs.

A good rule: Make upgrades easy to accept and equally easy to decline.

Avoid preselecting paid extras or hiding additional charges. Transparent pricing builds trust and reduces unpleasant surprises at checkout.

When customers feel in control, upselling becomes part of a positive ordering experience rather than an unwanted sales tactic.

4. Recommend Small Extras Before Checkout

The final stage of an online order presents another opportunity to suggest useful extras.

At this point, customers have already decided what they want. A small reminder about something they may have forgotten can be helpful.

For example:

"Would you like to add a dessert or drink?"

Restaurants can use this moment to recommend low-cost items such as cookies, sauces, beverages, or side dishes.

However, timing matters.

The recommendation should appear before the customer enters payment details, not after they've committed to completing the purchase.

Keep the message short and show only one or two suggestions.

Customers should also be able to continue checkout immediately without making another decision.

This approach can encourage incremental purchases without slowing down the ordering process.

Even modest increases in average order value can add up across hundreds of transactions.

5. Use Ordering History to Make Better Recommendations

Not every customer has the same preferences.

Some regularly order family meals. Others prefer lighter options, premium add-ons, or a particular dessert.

When restaurants have access to appropriate customer ordering history, they can use that information to create more relevant suggestions.

For example, a returning customer who frequently orders a particular beverage might appreciate seeing it suggested alongside their usual meal.

A customer who regularly purchases family bundles may find a similar combination useful during their next visit.

Recommendations should be based on actual customer preferences, not assumptions.

Restaurants can begin with simple insights:

  • Frequently purchased item combinations.
  • Popular add-ons for specific dishes.
  • Common repeat purchases.
  • Products customers often order together.

Customer information should be handled responsibly, with clear privacy practices and appropriate consent where required.

The goal isn't to make customers feel monitored. It's to reduce unnecessary searching and make ordering more convenient.

Personalization works best when it feels helpful, subtle, and optional.

How to Measure Whether Upselling Is Working

Implementing upselling tactics is only the beginning. Restaurants should also measure whether those tactics improve sales without creating friction.

A few useful metrics include:

Average Order Value (AOV): The average amount customers spend per order.

Add-On Attachment Rate: The percentage of orders that include suggested extras.

Checkout Completion Rate: The percentage of customers who complete checkout after starting the process.

Repeat Customer Rate: The percentage of customers who return and place another order.

An upselling strategy that increases average order value but causes more customers to abandon checkout may not be beneficial overall.

Restaurants should test small changes, compare results, and focus on improvements that support both revenue and customer satisfaction.

Conclusion: Make Every Suggestion Useful

Successful online upselling isn't about pressuring customers to buy more. It's about making relevant recommendations, simplifying choices, and helping customers enjoy a more complete ordering experience.

Thoughtful add-ons, convenient bundles, optional upgrades, timely checkout suggestions, and personalized recommendations can all create opportunities to increase average order value.

The best strategies are simple, transparent, and respectful of the customer.

Make Online Ordering Work Harder for Your Restaurant

MunchEm helps restaurants connect with customers through convenient online ordering, personalized offers, and loyalty opportunities.

Discover how smarter ordering experiences can encourage repeat purchases and create more opportunities to grow your restaurant's revenue.

Explore MunchEm at www.MunchEm.com

X
Name
Email
Mobile Number
How can we help?